How Does Obedience Affect The Working Relationship Between...

It has been over 40 years since Stanley Milgram s famous experiments on obedience. The topic of obedience has been explored for centuries and there continues to be more to learn. Why do people obey authority? Are some groups of people more prone to obey authority than others? Does the environment play a role in how far people go to obey orders? These questions were asked after the actions of Germany during World War II (Houghton 2009). The situationist perspective and bad barrel theory are basic theories of obedience. The situationist perspective claims that people will neglect their dispositions if placed in a powerful enough situation (Houghton 2009). The bad barrel theory, coined by Philip Zimbardo, says that if you put people in a bad situation, the situation can take over (Houghton 2009). Stanley Milgram s shock experiment and Philip Zimbardo s Stanford Prison Experiment are two popular experiments of obedience. How does obedience effect the working relationship between doctors and nurses? Is there a tipping point in which nurses refuse to carry out the doctor s orders? Is there a point where doctors refuse to work with nurses that question them? Does gender play a role in this working relationship? If so, how? Physicians know their professional status, but are aware that it is favorable for them to treat nurses with respect and acknowledge them as a valuable team member of the health team (Devine 1978). Nurses reported they felt that doctorsShow MoreRelatedMilgrams Research on Obedience811 Words   |  4 PagesMilgrams research on obedience: how and why it can help student nurses The report aims to: Describe the main aspects of Milgrams study on Obedience Explain why and how this research can be used to help prepare student nurses for working on hospital wards Contribute to the understanding of some of the challenges nurses may face in their working practices Background Stanley Milgram, a psychologist from Yale University, conducted a series of experiments on obedience to explain some of theRead MoreThe Changing Role of the Nurse2911 Words   |  12 PagesThe focus is the on the changing role of the nurse and why this has happened You have to chose an example from your own practice to describe and explain its relevance to practice boundaries between doctor and nurses , EXAMPLE BLOOD TAKING, SET IV BRANULLA You need to utilise relevant theories and concepts from the module, reference your work and include Malaysia code of conduct.You have to summarise the main issues and consider implications that the changing role has for your role, the professionRead MoreCollegiality: Attribute, Theory or Impossibility?3600 Words   |  15 PagesMerriam-Webster dictionary as the cooperative relationship of colleagues. Collegial relationships are those built upon respect between people (Curtin, 1995) and allow for the interchange and discussion of ideas from eac h member of a team (Williams, 1997). Among most professionals, acquiring and developing this characteristic assists in building many of the critical competencies of manager. Knowing how to build and strengthen collegial relationships improves teamwork, increases one self-managementRead MoreWhat Sets Us Apart And The Challenges I Go?2346 Words   |  10 Pagesor majorities. I will be explaining what sets us apart and the challenges I go through in terms of dating, mate selection, marriage, and sexuality. Also, in regards to raising children, extended family, gender roles, divorce, and lastly, how my ethnicity affects my family’s response to a stressing event. Dating For Filipinos, in terms of dating, it can be very traditional. A man who is serious about courting a girl would court her parents before they can even make it official. For instance, theRead Moredescribe how the body responds to stress4612 Words   |  19 Pagesï » ¿Describe how the body responds to stress (6 marks) Acute stress causes the arousal of the autonomic nervous system (ANS). The ANS comprises of the sympathetic nervous system (SNS) which prepares the individual for ‘fight or flight’ and the parasympathetic branch, which returns the individual to their original state of relaxation. Part of the SNS response is the sympathetic adrenal system (SAM), this system along with the SNS is collectively called the sympathomedullary pathway. The SNS is activatedRead MorePhysical Restraint And Nursing Home Facilities5608 Words   |  23 Pagesbehavioral problems. The decrease of behavioral problems also occurred when an individual was released from being restrained. Castle and Mor, 1998 note that various literature describe that the use of physical restraint in nursing home facilities can vary between 4 to 68%. There are favorable mechanisms that are used when associated with physical restraint use in so that the residents and/or individuals not injured, and decrease the amount of elo ping behavior. Physical restraints devices run the gamut fromRead MoreAnalysis Of One Flew Over The Cuckoo s Nest 3755 Words   |  16 PagesClerambault’s syndrome which habitually affects women. While Plath struggled with the â€Å"ardent feminist within her’’, she sought to â€Å"embrace the ideology of feminineness that had been indoctrinated into the women of her generation’’ leading to a â€Å"schizophrenic split within herself’’, a struggle not shared by McEwan and Kesey. Kesey described himself as ‘’comfortable with {his} identity and masculinity’’ as he understood he was too young to be a beatnik, and too old to be a hippie’’ and so hisRead MoreCommunication And Health And Social Care9509 Words   |  39 Pagesbased or of ideas that are suggested to explain a fact or event or, more generally, an opinion or explanation. (Cambridge Dictionary, 2014) In health and social care settings effective communication between professionals and patients is essential, as a result, it is imperative to understand theories of how people learn and develop in order to apply this to enhance communication. Theories of learning are 1) Classical conditioning (involuntary behavior) where learning is by association (Pavlov, 1927)Read Moreethical decision making16006 Words   |  65 Pageshealth nurses in each district were asked to select patients for the medication program. A terminally ill cancer patient who is in great pain begs the nurse for more medication than the physician has ordered. What should the nurse do? A man was diagnosed and treated for a venereal infection by his family nurse practitioner. He agreed that his wife should also be treated but he did not want her to know that he acquired the disease from a prostitute and infected her. He asked the nurse practitionerRead MoreThe Vogue Of The Lady3547 Words   |  15 Pageshad a large impact on American parents intent on training girls to be polished but congenial, obedient as daughters and future wives† among the community. While this study highlights data on Mary Lyon on a deeper context, their findings also discuses how the mere presence of economic necessity and religious zeal in the society significantly affected women’s academic development. In terms of the author’s evaluation, In the Company of Educated Women outlines a strong narrative on these dimensions and